Best Milkshakes in New York, New York
Ranked by 9 community votes for 2026. FoodMedals members award Gold, Silver & Bronze medals to their favorites.
As of May 11, 2026, Milk Bar leads the milkshakes rankings in New York, New York with 8 points from community votes, followed by Sugar Factory New York - Time Square at 6 points and Jerrell's BETR BRGR at 4 points.
Looking for the best milkshakes in New York? FoodMedals tracks 3 restaurants across New York, New York serving milkshakes, with 9 community votes cast in 2026. Milk Bar currently leads the 2026 rankings.
2
1
1
Also Popular in New York
🏆
Think we're missing a spot?
Award your own Gold, Silver & Bronze for Milkshakes in New York.
Award your medals for New York