A spread of delicious food dishes
mac and cheese

Best Mac & Cheese in New York, New York

Ranked by 12 community votes for 2026. FoodMedals members award Gold, Silver & Bronze medals to their favorites.

#1
S'MAC
197 1st Ave, New York, NY
Gold3Silver111 pts
#2
Jacob's Pickles
680 Columbus Ave, New York, NY
Gold1Silver2Bronze18 pts
#3
Mom's Kitchen and Bar
701 9th Ave, New York, NY
Silver1Bronze13 pts

Full Rankings

4
Maison Pickle
Bronze22 pts
5
Melba's
0 pts

Also Popular in New York

🍕Best Pizza🌮Best TacosramenBest Ramen🍔Best CheeseburgersdumplingsBest Dumplings🍟Best French Fries
🏆

Think we're missing a spot?

Award your own Gold, Silver & Bronze for Mac & Cheese in New York.

Award your medals for New York